Serious Question: Should NDSU Be Ranked Ahead Of UCF?

Central Florida debuted at No. 12 in last night’s College Football Playoff rankings release.

Many referred to that as “proper” placement.

Many are very dumb misinformed.

Last night, our very own Kyle Bratke made the comment on Twitter dot com that UCF didn’t even deserve to be ranked in the top 25. And, you might say, “Bratke was just upset that the Knights were ranked ahead of West Virginia.” And, if you said that, you’d be right. That, alone, is nothing short of hysterical.

But that’s really just tip of the proverbial iceberg.

Central Florida has exactly zero wins against a team currently above .500. Its banner win this season came against 4-4 Pitt. Sick.

Nevermind the fact that, based on resumé alone, UCF should be ranked behind Utah State and Fresno State. If we’re really going to act like the Knights are the twelfth-best team in the country right now, FCS power North Dakota State should probably be ranked inside the top 10.

Big J h/t to redditor Inthetop11 for doing the heavy lifting on the following research:

  • UCF has the 125th-ranked strength of schedule across Division I. North Dakota State checks in at No. 126.
  • NDSU is winning its games by an average score of 40-13. UCF is winning by an average score of 44-18.
  • UCF’s Sagarin ranking is No. 29. NDSU is ranked 22nd.

And, since we’re clearly propping up UCF based on past achievements and its ongoing win streak, here’s some historical data to consider:

  • North Dakota State doesn’t seem to share UCF’s ongoing struggle to schedule quality P5 teams. Since 2013, the Bison have knocked off Kansas State, Iowa State and, most recently, No. 13 Iowa in 2016.
  • NDSU has won seven straight conference championships and has made seven consecutive FCS semifinals. The latter is a record.
  • NDSU has won 14 consecutive games.

If you can talk yourself into taking Central Florida seriously based on a whole bunch of variables that are completely unrelated to playing and beating actual good football teams, then you ought to be able to talk yourself into North Dakota State.

So, sure, the system is broken. UCF should be given a chance. Yada, yada, yada. But if all of that’s true, then the mighty Bison should be knocking on the door, as well.


Martell Wins Immediate Eligibility, Sets Major NCAA Precedent

Like the guy who took his job at Ohio State, Tate Martell petitioned the NCAA for immediate eligibility following his transfer to Miami back in January.

There May Legitimately Be An Entire Pro Bowl Defense In This Draft


The 1996 NFL Draft class is the gold standard for defensive hauls in a single year.

Kyler Murray Should (And Will) Be The No. 1 Pick In The NFL Draft

It’s awkward.

'Area 51' Will Be Immediately Tested By Spurrier, Gilbert

Two of the most impressive performances of the Alliance of American Football’s opening weekend belonged to Orlando and San Antonio—and could not have been more different.

FloSports Announces Partnership With National Gridiron League

Today, FloSports, the innovator in live digital sports and original content, announced a partnership with the National Gridiron League to provide live and on-demand coverage of more than 100 regular-season games, plus the championship game during the 2019 and 2020 seasons exclusively on

Remember Garrett Gilbert? Well, He's Back

Remember Garrett Gilbert? Yes, that Garrett Gilbert—the five-star quarterback prospect out of famed Lake Travis (TX) High School.

AAF 101: A Crash Course On The Alliance Of American Football

It is with a substantial level of excitement that we must acknowledge, for the first time in a very, very long time, football did not end with a thud at the conclusion of Sunday night’s snooze fest of a Super Bowl.

Your Comprehensive All-Twitter Super Bowl Preview

Twitter is a magical place during the week leading up to the Super Bowl and this year has been no exception.

Prop Bets Crash Course: How To Blow Cash During The Super Bowl

The Super Bowl vastly transcends the traditional football audience in a way that no other sporting event can even remotely compare to—thanks, in large part, to the abundance of alternative entertainment that is, in many cases, only loosely tied to the game, itself.

Andy Isabella Led All Receivers At The Senior Bowl Because Of Course He Did


Unlock this video, live events, and more with a subscription!

Get Started

Already a subscriber? Log In

If you're new to the Andy Isabella Experience, well, welcome.